User Defined Functions (UDF) vs VBA Macros in Excel

Rick Akura on
Learn about the advantages and drawbacks of custom UDF functions and VBA macros, and determine which one to use for your Excel tasks.

Learn about the advantages and drawbacks of custom UDF functions and VBA macros, and determine which one to use for your Excel tasks.

User Defined Functions (UDF) vs VBA Macros

In Excel, there are two powerful features called User Defined Functions (UDFs) and VBA macros. Both can help you do things faster and easier. But they work a little differently, so it's important to know what each one is good for. 

In this article, we'll explain the advantages and drawbacks of each one, to help you choose which one to use. It doesn't matter if you're new to Excel or already an expert. 

By the end of this article, you'll understand how to use these features to make your Excel work better. Let's get started!

What is UDFs and VBA macros

In Excel, there are two tools called User Defined Functions (UDFs) and VBA Macros. UDFs are like special calculators that people can make for Excel. 

what is UDFs and VBA functions

They help you do math or other tasks that Excel doesn't already know how to do. So, you can use UDFs to create custom formulas or functions.

On the other hand, VBA Macros are like little computer programs that people can write to do tasks in Excel automatically. Macros can do a lot of things like:

  • Formatting cells
  • Filling out forms
  • Even sending emails

VBA is a type of computer language that people can use to write these macros. So, if someone knows how to write VBA code, they can create powerful tools to help them work faster and smarter in Excel.

Why use Custom UDF Function and VBA Macros?

There are several reasons why you might want to use Custom UDF Functions and VBA Macros in Excel:

  1. To automate repetitive tasks: If you find yourself performing the same tasks over and over again in Excel, UDFs and VBA macros can help automate these tasks.
  2. To customize Excel to your needs: Sometimes the built-in functions in Excel aren't enough to solve a problem. In this case, UDFs and VBA macros can be used to create custom solutions that fit your specific needs.
  3. To perform advanced calculations: UDFs can do math and calculations that the normal formulas in Excel can't do, making them ideal for solving more complex problems.
  4. To improve efficiency: By using UDFs and VBA macros, you can streamline your workflow and complete tasks more efficiently. This can save you time and improve your productivity.
  5. To create user-friendly solutions: By turning complex formulas into a single function or macro, you can create more user-friendly solutions that are easy for others to use and understand.

UDFs and VBA macros can be incredibly useful tools for Excel users who want to customize their experience, automate tasks, and solve more complex problems.

Benefits of using UDFs in Excel

When working with Excel, using User-Defined Functions (UDFs) can be really helpful. UDFs can do math and calculations that the normal formulas in Excel can't do. 

Benefits of UDF in Excel

Here are 5 Benefits of Using UDFs in Excel

  • Perform advanced calculations: UDFs can do math and calculations that standard Excel formulas can't, allowing you to solve more complex problems.
  • Save time and energy: You can take long and complicated formulas and turn them into a single, easy-to-use function, making your work more efficient.
  • Avoid errors: Using UDFs can help you avoid mistakes when dealing with complex calculations, as the function will perform the same way every time.
  • Customizable: UDFs can be customized to fit your specific needs, providing you with greater flexibility in your work.
  • Increased accuracy: UDFs can help you achieve greater accuracy in your calculations, leading to more reliable results.

Benefits of using VBA macros in Excel

VBA Macros are a really useful tool for people who work with Excel. They can make tasks that you do over and over again much easier and faster. 

Benefits of VBA macros

For example: Let's say you have to create a report every week. With VBA macros, you can automate the process of creating the report. 

This means that you don't have to do it manually every week. 

You can use VBA macros to automate these tasks so that you can focus on more important work. Macros are like little computer programs that you can write to do exactly what you need them to do. 

This means that you can create customized charts and reports, and perform word- and data-processing functions that would take a long time to do by hand. Overall, VBA macros can save you a lot of time and make your work in Excel much more efficient.

Differences between UDFs and VBA macros

User-Defined Functions (UDFs) and VBA macros are two different tools you can use in Excel to make your work easier. The way they work is different. 

  1. When you create a UDF, you use a special editor in Excel called the Visual Basic Editor. 
  2. You write the code for your function using the word "Function" at the beginning and "End Function" at the end. 

This tells Excel that you are creating a custom function that you can use in your worksheet.

On the other hand, when you record a macro, you are telling Excel to record all the steps you take in a particular task. This can include:

  • Formatting cells
  • Entering data
  • Using other functions.

You start with the word "Sub" and end with "End Sub". Macros can be a lot more flexible than UDFs because you can record almost any action you take in Excel.

Another difference between UDFs and VBA macros is the operators you can use. UDFs can't use all the operators that are available in VBA macros. 

This means that some tasks can only be done with macros, while others can only be done with UDFs. Both UDFs and VBA macros have their strengths and weaknesses, and knowing how to use both can make you more efficient in Excel.

Limitations of UDFs in Excel

Although User-Defined Functions (UDFs) in Excel can be very useful, they also have some limitations:

  1. They cannot copy and paste cells to other areas of the worksheet. This means that if you want to move data from one cell to another, you'll need to use a different function or tool. 
  2. UDFs cannot change the active worksheet, which means that they can't be used to move between different sheets in your workbook.
  3. Another limitation of UDFs is that they can't change the formatting of the active cell. 

For example: If you want to display different values in a cell depending on certain criteria, you'll need to use conditional formatting instead. UDFs can be used to perform calculations and return values, but they can't change the appearance of a cell on their own.

It's important to keep these limitations in mind when using UDFs in Excel. While they can be a powerful tool for custom calculations and functions, they may not be able to do everything you need them to do.

Limitations of VBA macros in Excel

Visual Basic for Applications (VBA) macros in Excel are great for automating repetitive tasks and making complicated operations simpler. However, there are some limitations to what they can do. 

  1. A single line of code cannot be longer than 8,192 characters. If you need to write a longer macro, you'll need to split it into multiple lines of code.
  2. They require some programming knowledge to use effectively. If you're not familiar with programming concepts, it may be challenging to create complex macros that work correctly. 
  3. Macros can sometimes cause issues if they're not written correctly or if they conflict with other macros or add-ins.

Despite these limitations, VBA macros can be a powerful tool for automating tasks and increasing productivity in Excel. With some programming knowledge and careful planning, you can create macros that make your work much easier and faster.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, both UDFs and VBA macros have their own advantages and drawbacks. UDFs are useful for performing custom calculations and can save time by converting complex formulas into a single function. 

VBA macros, on the other hand, are beneficial for automating repetitive tasks and can be used for a wide range of applications. 

Ultimately, the choice between using a UDF or a VBA macro depends on the specific needs of the user and the task at hand.

One more thing

We’re glad you’re read this article/blog upto here :) Thank you for reading.

If you have a second, please share this article on your socials; someone else may benefit too. 

Subscribe to our newsletter and be the first to read our future articles, reviews, and blog post right in your email inbox. We also offer deals, promotions, and updates on our products and share them via email. You won’t miss one.

Related articles 

>How to insert page break in Excel worksheet
>Expense Record & Tracking Sheet Templates for Excel
>How to Calculate CAGR in Excel

Tags: Comparisons